dsl-logo

Home Loans

Personal Loans

Car Loans

Business Loans

Credit Cards

Banking

dsl-logo
dsl-logo

Home Loans

Personal Loans

Car Loans

Business Loans

Credit Cards

Banking

Benefits and disadvantages of private health insurance

Money.com.au's Senior Finance Writer, Jared Mullane

Written By

Jared Mullane

Last updated14 November 2024

The benefits of private health insurance include having a wider choice of care providers and coverage for services not covered by Medicare. But premiums can be expensive, and you typically won’t be covered for all costs. So, is private health insurance worth it overall?

Benefits and disadvantages of private health insurance

Money.com.au's Senior Finance Writer, Jared Mullane

Written By

Jared Mullane

Last updated14 November 2024

The benefits of private health insurance include having a wider choice of care providers and coverage for services not covered by Medicare. But premiums can be expensive, and you typically won’t be covered for all costs. So, is private health insurance worth it overall?

Why do people get private health insurance in Australia?

One of the main selling points of private health insurance is that it gives you access to a range of options and medical services beyond what’s covered by Medicare - Australia’s public healthcare system. It allows you to choose your healthcare providers, receive treatment in private hospitals, and access elective surgeries and specialist consultations more quickly.

You can also opt for Extras cover, either as a standalone policy or combined with Hospital cover. This type of coverage helps pay for services like dental, optical, and physiotherapy, which can significantly lower your out-of-pocket costs.

Benefits of private health insurance

Here are some benefits of private health insurance:

1

Greater choice of healthcare providers

You may be able to choose your own doctor, specialist, and hospital, allowing you to have a greater degree of control over your care. You can also be treated as a private patient in a private hospital, which can lead to a more personalised healthcare experience.

2

Coverage for additional services

You can take out Extras cover that helps pay for services not covered by Medicare. This can include dental care, optical services, physiotherapy, chiropractic treatments, and more, reducing your out-of-pocket expenses.

3

Quicker access to medical treatments

You usually face shorter waiting times for medical treatments and surgeries. This is especially beneficial for elective procedures, allowing you to receive timely care without the delays often found in the public healthcare system.

To give you an idea, the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) reported that in 2022-23, the waiting times for common elective surgeries were 175 days for total hip replacement and 283 days for myringoplasty/tympanoplasty (eardrum surgery).

4

Tax savings

Taking out Hospital cover can lead to tax savings by allowing you to avoid the Medicare Levy Surcharge (MLS) if your income exceeds a certain threshold. This means you won’t have to pay additional taxes if you’re in a higher income bracket.

For the 2023-24 financial year, there is no MLS surcharge for individuals earning $97,000 or less and for families earning $194,000 or less. But for incomes above that, the MLS is tiered based on income thresholds, ranging from 1% to 1.5%, according to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).

5

Cost is subsidised for eligible Australians

Most Australians with private health insurance receive a rebate from the Federal Government to help reduce their premium costs. The Private Health Insurance Rebate is determined by both income and age, with savings of between 8.202% and 32.812% for individuals earning less than $151,001 or up to $302,000 for families.

Insurers can also offer discounts of up to 10% on hospital premiums for individuals aged 18 to 29. This discount remains in place until you turn 41, at which point it will be gradually phased out, according to PrivateHealth.gov.au. The age-based discount is 2% for each year under 30, reaching a maximum of 10% for those aged 18 to 25.

Getting health insurance before the age of 31 also means you won’t be stung by the Lifetime Health Cover (LHC) loading. This loading imposes an extra 2% on your premiums for each year you go without coverage after turning 31, making it beneficial to get in early.

6

Peace of mind and security

Private health insurance provides peace of mind and security knowing that you have timely access to necessary medical care when you need it. It allows you to manage potential health issues proactively, knowing that you can choose your healthcare providers, avoid long waiting times, and receive treatment in comfortable, private settings.

Many providers offer health insurance sign-up deals for switching funds. These may include offering free cover for a period of time, waiving waiting periods for Extras cover or providing cashback to help with your premiums. However, it’s important to remember that these incentives might not always offset the overall cost difference versus choosing a cheaper policy with no special offer. Be sure to carefully compare the benefits and coverage of different policies to ensure you’re making the best choice for your needs.

Disadvantages of private health insurance

Here are some disadvantages of private health insurance:

1

Costly premiums

Health insurance can be expensive, with monthly premiums adding pressure to already tight household budgets, particularly for comprehensive coverage.

The cost of health insurance premiums can vary depending on several factors. This includes the type of coverage you choose (Hospital, Extras, or both), whether you're looking for a singles policy, or getting covered as a couple, family, or single-parent family. Your age, and where you live are also factors. So too is your household income, as it affects your eligibility for the Private Health Insurance Rebate.

Additionally, keep in mind that premiums typically increase each year on April 1.

Analysis by Money.com.au shows that premiums for Extras cover can range from $20 to $295 per month; Hospital cover could cost from $80 to $550 per month, while combined Hospital and Extras cover could set you back anywhere between $90 to $850 per month.

2

It won’t cover everything

Even with private health insurance, you may still face out-of-pocket expenses for certain services, including co-payments and excess fees.

A co-payment is a fixed amount you pay out-of-pocket for certain services or treatments, in addition to what your health insurance covers. For example, if you’re a private patient in a hospital, your insurer might pay part of the cost, but you’ll need to cover the rest. Hospital co-payments typically range from $50 to $100 per night.

Excess fees are amounts that you agree to pay when making a claim before your insurer covers the rest of the costs. For example, if you have Hospital cover with a $750 excess and you undergo a surgery that costs $3,000, you would pay $750 and the insurer would pay the remaining $2,250. Choosing a higher excess usually results in lower premium costs, while a lower excess can lead to higher premiums.

3

Complicated fineprint

The fineprint on your policy can be complicated and difficult to understand. It’s easy to overlook important details, such as exclusions or waiting periods for specific treatments. This can lead to potential misunderstandings about what the policy actually covers.

Each insurance policy includes a Product Disclosure Statement (PDS), which typically ranges from two to 10 pages. The PDS outlines what’s covered and what isn’t under your specific level of cover. It also details any co-payments and excess fees, along with waiting periods.

The information is often accompanied by lengthy disclaimers in small print, which can be overwhelming, especially when comparing multiple policies. This complexity may make it difficult to identify which plan best suits your needs.

4

Limited coverage

Some policies may have restrictions on coverage, meaning certain services or treatments may not be included or may come with limits. This is particularly the case if you choose a basic level of cover.

For example, on a Basic Tier Hospital policy, certain treatments may be included but as “restricted cover” only. That could mean, for example, that only shared room accommodation in a public hospital is covered. Under that level of cover you could incur significant out-of-pocket costs if you receive treatment in a private hospital or choose a private room in a public hospital. This won’t necessarily align with some people’s expectations of what they will get with even a basic level of private health insurance.

5

Waiting periods

Health insurance policies generally have waiting periods for specific treatments or services. For example, with Hospital cover, you’ll usually need to wait up to two months for most services before you can claim any benefits, or up to 12 months for pre-existing conditions and pregnancy and birth-related treatments.

With Extras cover, waiting periods also apply. For instance, you might face a six-month wait for optical and 12 months for major dental.

Keep an eye out providers offering health insurance with no waiting period on selected Extras.

6

Gaps in your coverage can impact your premiums

If you don’t maintain continuous coverage, you may face higher premiums later due to the LHC loading, which can penalise you if you take breaks in your insurance.

According to Queensland Country Health, you can drop your Hospital cover for a total of up to two years and 364 days throughout your life without affecting your loading. However, if you go without coverage for more than that, your loading will increase by 2% for each additional year.

7

You may be restricted to certain healthcare providers

Some insurance funds require you to use specific hospitals or providers to receive full benefits, limiting your choice of care.

For example, if you’re with Medibank and they don’t have an agreement with a specific private hospital or medical practice, you may face higher costs for treatment. This can be a major drawback, especially if you live in a regional area with fewer healthcare options.

Public healthcare vs private health insurance

Health service

In-hospital services

What does Medicare cover?

  • You may receive treatment as a public patient in either a public or private hospital.

  • Covers the cost of your treatment.

  • You cannot choose your hospital, doctor or specialist as a public patient.

What does private health insurance cover?

  • Depending on your coverage, your health insurance provider may cover some or all of your private patient hospital costs, including accommodation.

  • Medicare covers part of the doctors’ fees, while your health insurer takes care of the remaining costs.

Health service

Specialist services outside of hospital

What does Medicare cover?

  • Covers some or all of the costs for services like GP visits, diagnostic imaging, and tests.

What does private health insurance cover?

  • Health insurance providers cannot offer cover for most of these services.

Health service

Other services outside of hospital

What does Medicare cover?

  • Covers some or all of the costs for services such as dental care for certain children, eye exams, and allied health services under specific conditions.

What does private health insurance cover?

  • You can select policies that cover some or all of the costs for various services outside of hospital care. This can include general dental, optometry, physiotherapy, chiro, orthodontics, remedial massage, and more.

Health service

Prescription medicines

What does Medicare cover?

What does private health insurance cover?

  • You can choose policies that cover some prescription medications not included in the PBS, such as antibiotics, asthma medications, and contraceptive pills.

Health service

Prostheses

What does Medicare cover?

  • The costs of implanted prostheses are covered for public patients.

What does private health insurance cover?

  • If your policy includes coverage for the procedure to implant a prosthesis, it will also cover some or all of the associated costs for the prosthesis itself.

Health service

Ambulance

What does Medicare cover?

  • Queensland and Tasmania are the only states that provide coverage for emergency transport costs.

  • Other states and territories have different eligibility requirements for ambulance cover.

What does private health insurance cover?

  • You can choose policies that cover ambulance costs not included in your state or territory government's coverage.

Health service

Pregnancy and birth

What does Medicare cover?

  • You may be covered for certain costs, including visiting a doctor, routine pregnancy tests, care from midwives and obstetricians, your stay as a public patient in a public hospital, some immunisations, and pregnancy counselling.

What does private health insurance cover?

  • You can select policies that cover some of the costs associated with pregnancy, birth and miscarriage.

  • Some Hospital cover policies may allow you to stay in a private room, but this depends on availability. You might also have the option to choose your private hospital and obstetrician.

  • Some Extras cover policies may pay a benefit towards services such as postnatal care.

Health service What does Medicare cover?What does private health insurance cover?

In-hospital services

  • You may receive treatment as a public patient in either a public or private hospital.

  • Covers the cost of your treatment.

  • You cannot choose your hospital, doctor or specialist as a public patient.

  • Depending on your coverage, your health insurance provider may cover some or all of your private patient hospital costs, including accommodation.

  • Medicare covers part of the doctors’ fees, while your health insurer takes care of the remaining costs.

Specialist services outside of hospital

  • Covers some or all of the costs for services like GP visits, diagnostic imaging, and tests.
  • Health insurance providers cannot offer cover for most of these services.

Other services outside of hospital

  • Covers some or all of the costs for services such as dental care for certain children, eye exams, and allied health services under specific conditions.
  • You can select policies that cover some or all of the costs for various services outside of hospital care. This can include general dental, optometry, physiotherapy, chiro, orthodontics, remedial massage, and more.

Prescription medicines

  • You can choose policies that cover some prescription medications not included in the PBS, such as antibiotics, asthma medications, and contraceptive pills.

Prostheses

  • The costs of implanted prostheses are covered for public patients.
  • If your policy includes coverage for the procedure to implant a prosthesis, it will also cover some or all of the associated costs for the prosthesis itself.

Ambulance

  • Queensland and Tasmania are the only states that provide coverage for emergency transport costs.

  • Other states and territories have different eligibility requirements for ambulance cover.

  • You can choose policies that cover ambulance costs not included in your state or territory government's coverage.

Pregnancy and birth

  • You may be covered for certain costs, including visiting a doctor, routine pregnancy tests, care from midwives and obstetricians, your stay as a public patient in a public hospital, some immunisations, and pregnancy counselling.
  • You can select policies that cover some of the costs associated with pregnancy, birth and miscarriage.

  • Some Hospital cover policies may allow you to stay in a private room, but this depends on availability. You might also have the option to choose your private hospital and obstetrician.

  • Some Extras cover policies may pay a benefit towards services such as postnatal care.

Source: Department of Health and Aged Care, About private health insurance. MyGov.com.au, Pregnancy Care

Do I need private health insurance?

Deciding whether private health insurance is right for you depends on your individual healthcare needs, financial situation, and lifestyle. For instance, if you frequently require medical services, have specific health concerns, or want the flexibility to choose your healthcare providers, taking out cover can be worthwhile.

On the other hand, private health insurance may not be necessary for everyone. If you’re generally healthy and rarely visit the doctor, the cost of premiums might outweigh the benefits. For example, if you’re young with no chronic health conditions, you may find that relying on the public healthcare system meets your needs.

Cost is an important consideration too. If you’re trying to figure out if private health insurance will be worth the money, be sure to factor the cost now and also that premiums typically rise each year on April 1. For instance, in 2024, the average increase was 3.03%.

You’ll also want to consider any tax implications that may apply to your situation, including eligibility for a rebate, which can help reduce your overall costs. Lastly, look out for discounts and special offers that insurers promote from time to time, as these can take the sting out of the cost, initially at least.

Jared Mullane is a finance writer with more than eight years of experience at some of Australia’s biggest finance and consumer brands. His areas of expertise include energy, home loans, personal finance and insurance.

Sean Callery is the Editor of Money.com.au. He has over 15 years of international experience. He is qualified with a Certificate IV in Finance and Mortgage Broking (FNS40821) and is compliant to provide general advice in Tier 1 General Insurance (RG 146) products.

Important information

General information only

The information on this page is general in nature and has been prepared without considering your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider whether the information provided and the nature of any health insurance product is suitable for you and seek independent advice if necessary.

We are not providing you with a recommendation or suggestion about a particular product. You should read the relevant disclosure statements or other offer documents before deciding whether to apply for or continue to use a particular product.

What products, features and information are shown

While we make every effort to ensure all products available in Australia are shown in our comparison tables, we do not guarantee that all products are included.

Our product comparisons may not compare all product features and attributes relevant to you.

Product information is subject to change without notice. Before acting on any information, you should confirm the relevant product information with the provider.

How health insurance offers are sorted

Products shown are sorted alphabetically by provider name.

logo

Our Money Promise

Money Pty Ltd (trading as Money) (ABN 42 626 094 773) Australian Credit Licence 528698 provides information about credit products. Money does not compare all products or issuers available in Australia. We are not a broker or credit provider and when we provide information via this website, we are not providing you with a recommendation or suggestion about a particular credit product. We may receive a commission when you apply for a home loan as a result of outbound links on this website.

This material has been prepared by Money Pty Limited (ABN 40 664 954 536) (Money, ‘us’ or ‘we’). Money is a corporate authorised representative (CAR 001307399) of 62 Consulting Pty Limited (ABN 88 664 809 303) (AFSL 548573) (62C). The material is for general information only and is not an offer for the purchase or sale of any financial product or service. The material is not intended to provide you with financial or tax advice and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Although we believe that the material is correct, no warranty of accuracy, reliability or completeness is given, except for liability under statute which cannot be excluded. Please note that past performance may not be indicative of future performance and that no guarantee of performance, the return of capital or a particular rate of return is given by 62C, Money, any of their related body corporates or any other person. To the maximum extent possible, 62C, Money, their related body corporates or any other person do not accept any liability for any statement in this material.

The information on this website is intended to be general in nature and has been prepared without considering your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should read the relevant disclosure statements or other offer documents prior to making a decision about a credit product and seek independent financial advice. Whilst Money.com.au endeavours to ensure the accuracy of the information provided on this website, no responsibility is accepted by us for any errors, omissions or any inaccurate information on this website.

Interest rates, fees and charges are subject to change without notice. Before acting on any information, you should confirm the interest rates, fees, charges and product information with the provider. For clarity, where we have used the terms “lowest” or “best” these relate solely to the rates of interest offered by the provider and not on any other factor. The application of these terms to a particular product is subject to change without notice if the provider changes their rates.

The calculator provided on money.com.au is intended for informational and illustrative purposes only. The results generated by this calculator are based on the inputs you provide and the assumptions set by us. These results should not be considered as financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any financial product. By using this calculator, you acknowledge and agree to the terms set out in this disclaimer. For more detailed information, please review our full terms and conditions on the website.

Assumptions:

  • The calculations do not account for changes in interest rates or other market conditions that may occur.
  • Results are approximations and may differ from actual payment schedules or amounts.
  • The calculator does not include all fees and charges that you may incur in relation to a financial product.

Limitation

  • This calculator does not guarantee the availability of any financial product or the accuracy of the calculations. Please consult a financial advisor or the relevant product provider to obtain specific advice tailored to your circumstances.
  • money.com.au does not accept any liability for errors or omissions, or for any loss you may suffer as a result of relying on these calculations.
Money Pty Ltd trading as Money

ABN: 42 626 094 773 / ACL: 528698 / AFCA: 83955
Money is a corporate authorised representative (CAR 001307399) of 62 Consulting Pty Limited (ABN 88 664 809 303) (AFSL 548573) (62C)
aboriginal-and-torres-strait

Money acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders as the traditional custodians of country throughout Australia and their continuing connection to land, waters and community.

© Copyright 2024 Money Pty Ltd.